Female Hysteria (!!!)
Sunday, January 18th, 2009Once, someone I cared about a lot and later parted ways with called me out on my feminism when we were having words. Said that I was all talk, and that I went on and on about how women deserved to be respected and to think and do what they thought and did without it being called into question, but that when it came to myself I was just pathetic and consumed by my emotions, disrespecting myself and allowing myself to be ruled by need.I guess I’m paraphrasing wildly here because I made a point of not saving that conversation. But anyway, it’s come back into my head lately. I’ve been really down, and I’ve been down over valid things, but I keep having this feeling that if I were a stronger, smarter woman I wouldn’t have gotten myself into feeling this way.So then I examine it (and re-examine it… and re-examine it…) and determine what I already knew: I can’t help how I feel and I don’t really have much control over the things that are upsetting me. So all I can do is try to ride it out and be nice to myself. Instead of, y’know, blaming myself for feeling bad on TOP of everything.And here’s the obvious realization I’ve come to: experiencing emotional pain does not make you a weak person. Like, duh. It just makes you human.I’ve been thinking about it from a feminist perspective, thusly: People still seem to look at emotion as a more feminine trait.People say things like: women are more in tune with their emotions. Women are more intuitive. Women are more warm and nurturing. Women are more emotional while men are more rational.For starters, these statements are just full of blatant sexism that hurts women AND men. And I don’t believe one word. Women and men have equal capacity to be emotional, caring, supportive and self-aware. What IS true is that culturally, women are taught that it’s OK (natural!) to be emotional whereas men are taught that it’s manly to hide it. (As a broad generalization that obviously has exceptions–I speak of cultural trends here.)Secondly, these statements that SEEM to be positive statements about women (except for perhaps the last one) all have much darker sentiments attached to them: Women are hysterical and too emotional. Women are not in control of themselves and ruled by their hormones.* Women are drama queens and can’t leave well enough alone. (Have you noticed there is no male equivalent for the term “drama queen”?)Like so much that is sexist, women take themselves to task for it too. Women get mad at themselves forloving too much. “I just shouldn’t care so much. I hurt MYSELF by caring.” CAN WE JUST GET REAL FOR A MINUTE AND RECOGNIZE THAT MAKING STRONG EMOTIONAL CONNECTIONS IS WHAT MAKES LIFE BEAUTIFUL AND, UNFORTUNATELY, IT LEAVES A PERSON OPEN TO PAIN.Okay? Srsly. And this isn’t a SOLELY female problem, I should point out — I know men who also feel that they “love too much”. Not to mention how society totally shoots down men who try to be open and emotional. I opine, however, that part of the reason there’s this big taboo on CARING is that it’s seen as a female trait and is therefore undesirable. Certainly, Big Manly Men never find themselves in the embarrassing situation of caring too much. Nooooo, when they feel down they just go shoot things with four legs and pee on trees in the woods and stuff! This reminds them that they are Manly and above such things as emotions.All us other emo schmucks are just being big dumb GIRLS by acknowledging our feelings. Right?This post has been difficult to write because it’s something that’s very close to home at the moment.I’m still locked in the “I’m so emotional and I can’t help it but doesn’t that make me a weak hateable person?” struggle right now. So, my own self doubt has made it difficult for me to put my thoughts on this into words. But I’ll tell you what: lately, I’ve finally developed the confidence to start judging myself with the same criteria that I use for everyone else. And I found something out: I like myself. I think I’m honorable, kind and sweet, and couldn’t be without being as emotional as I am. I have no intention of changing–not just because it’s not possible, but because I LIKE being this way.*Sexist culture likes to paint both women and men as being ruled by their hormones–women for being “too” emotional (every time a woman gets legitimately upset a man seems to be around to accuse her of PMSing) and men for being “overly” sexual (testosterone = fight and have sex!) I’d like to take a moment to point out what a load of crap that is. Firstly, each sex has an equal right to both sexuality and emotion, and secondly, WE’RE A PRETTY INTELLECTUALLY DEVELOPED SPECIES AND ARE CAPABLE OF CONTROLLING OURSELVES. For sure hormones have an emotional and physical effect on all of us–but hopefully none of us are so ignorant as to think that means that we have no say in how we comport ourselves. Hormones are not license for unpleasant behavior. If I may borrow an unpleasantly conservative-tinged term–”personal responsibility”, people.
